Outdoor
Behavioral Healthcare: Definitions, common practice, expected outcomes,
and a nationwide survey of programs.
By
Keith C. Russell and John C. Hendee
Executive Summary
Outdoor
behavioral healthcare (OBH) is an emerging intervention and treatment in
mental health practice to help adolescents overcome emotional, adjustment,
addiction, and psychological problems.
We have identified more than 100 OBH programs currently operating
in the United States, annually serving 10,000 clients and their families. OBH programs utilize elements of wilderness therapy to help
adolescents and their families, which include: immersion in an unfamiliar
environment, group living with peers, individual and group therapy
sessions, and educational curricula including backcountry travel and
wilderness living skills, all designed to reveal and address problem
behaviors and foster personal and social responsibility and emotional
growth of adolescent clients. A
family systems perspective guides treatment and aims to restore family
functioning and support, disrupted by the problem behaviors of the
adolescent clients.
The
goal of this publication and study is to improve understanding about
outdoor behavioral healthcare by parents, insurance companies, judicial
authorities and social service agencies, public land management agencies,
and Federal, State and local officials.
All these parties would seem to benefit from knowing more about OBH
as an emerging intervention and treatment to help troubled adolescents and
their families. Thus, we
define common elements of outdoor behavioral healthcare including
terminology, theoretical approaches, historical origins of the practice,
it’s growth over the last three decades, and the status of the OBH
industry based on a survey of 116 programs meeting OBH criteria.
We
classify two types of OBH programs: adjudicated and private placement
programs. Private
placement programs evolved from a variety of influences over
the last 30 years, including therapeutic approaches to camping, wilderness
challenge programs like Outward Bound, and the integration of therapeutic
professionals and processes into wilderness experiences.
Adjudicated programs grew out of need to expand traditional
social services to deal with increasing adolescent delinquency and
substance abuse. Four
common OBH program models are based on how and to what degree the
outdoor setting is utilized: 1) contained expedition programs,
where clients and the treatment team remain together on a wilderness
expedition; 2) continuous flow expedition programs,
where leaders, therapists, and clients rotate in and out of
on-going groups in the wilderness; 3) base camp expedition
programs, which have structured base camps in natural environments and
take expedition outings from the base; and, 4) residential expedition programs,
which include emotional growth schools, residential treatment centers, Job
Corps Centers, youth ranches, and other therapeutic designations
that use wilderness and outdoor treatment as a tool to augment
other services for resident clients.
Our
nationwide survey of OBH programs documents the nature and extent of the
OBH industry, including the number and types of programs, and the types of
clients they serve. A total
of 116 OBH programs were identified, with 86 participating in the survey,
yielding a 74 percent response rate.
Among respondents, private placement programs outnumbered
adjudicated programs more than 4 to 1, with 70 private placement compared
to only 16 adjudicated programs. More
than 80 percent of all responding OBH programs were licensed by a variety
of state agencies, ranging from judicial systems to departments of family
and youth services. A smaller percentage of adjudicated programs (31%) and more
than half of the private placement programs (57%) were nationally
certified by agencies such as the Council on Accreditation and the Joint
Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations (JCAHO).
Most
OBH programs served adolescent Caucasian males aged 13-17 years old with a
variety of emotional and behavioral disorders, with adjudicated programs
serving a more racially diverse clientele. OBH
programs are being used as an alternative treatment for adolescents not
successfully treated by traditional counseling services --more than
three-quarters of all clients had tried
other forms of counseling prior to OBH.
The cost of treatment ranges from
$123 per day for adjudicated to $161 per day for private placement
programs, averaging $151 per day. Most
clients did not receive third-party payment, but some did, indicating room
for more recognition by insurance companies, social service, and
adjudication agencies. Extrapolation
using data from the study suggest that as an industry, OBH may generate
$200 million per year in revenues and 420,000 field days use of public and
private lands.